PMMJ (cheetahmaster) wrote,
PMMJ
cheetahmaster

Riddle me this...

The Issue: I've been bit by the bug to run a game or something. Been mulling over it for a while now, and despite being stressed and busy, I think this would be a good release for me. So I have decided it is time to come out of retirement and run something.

The Conundrum: I cannot decide between running a larp for a whole bunch of people, or running a table-top game instead. Both sides have positives and negatives, which I will explicate here. Please, give me your advice, as I have been hemming and hawing for too long.

LARP vs. RPG

1.) Numbers
Advantage: Larp
There's a lot of people I would love to have in one of my games, and a lot of friends with whom I would like to game. And there's a handful of people who have run games for me in the past couple years, and I want to return the favor.
Even if I run two table-top games concurrently (which I am considering) I can fit considerably more people into a larp. I was originally aiming at a larp for 20-25 people, but to make it financially viable, I believe I would have to go to 30-35 people, and charge admission (for the site fees.) For a table-top game, I don't like running for more than five people in a group. So, maximum of ten, *if* I do two groups at the same time (like one Monday, one Sunday, with the same or similar stories.)

2.) Money
Advantage: Table-Top
I realize it's a self-imposed limit, but I do not want to run a large game at someone's house, or at school. I feel setting is very important in larp, and even with design work, I won't be able to get a 'different' enough setting out of either. After calling ten places, the only site I could find for rental for five or six hours would be a significant financial outlay, charging admission to the players along the lines of $15-20. Table-top, I buy some Mountain Dew and Cheetos.

3.) Time
Advantage: Table-Top
Either option will require a lot of background writing and storyteller 'work' (a broad and undefined category.) However, writing characters and plots for 35 people in a larp is a lot harder than the world background for a table-top. Even using an established setting, which would of course be edited to suit my tastes. Web pages need making for both, and while the larp system I have in mind is simple, it would require writing up as well. Table-top takes some of the pressure of the ST to explain all the rules.

So that's where I am leaning, but I want more input. The numbers thing is a big deal, but maybe I should not aim so high at first? What am I forgetting? Please comment below, and be prepared to defend your thesis... in mortal kombat.

URL:Opinions: Secrecy battles
MP3: Gustav Brom, "Bounty"
Quote: "It should be noted that the games of children are not games, and must be considered as their most serious actions." -Michel de Montaigne
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 0 comments